Win - Lose - Disconnect

[Don-Meedo]

hi to all



maybe this is not the time for it



but this thing annoying me from long time and i want to share it with you



i do battling with players .. always choose whose near from my lvl .. dont battle high or too low



in ((this account)) my record is 18 win 0 lose 0 disconnect



today i battled 5 ppl .. they all disconnect .. 2 of them ( they know there self ) disconnect in the last pokemon





the result of this is my record still same .. and they get 1 disconnect ...



i always do /info .. to know lvl and every thing .. which is very useful ..



how about when P1 disconnect .. the result will be 1 disconnect for him and 1 win for the other player ??



i just thought to share it coz i know that alot of player do that



and some time its unfair when you play fair and get 0 result ...



Thats all hope to talk about it ..

 

[BRGodEastwood]

right now when a player disconnects, they get 1 disconnect and lose rep.

 

[Dait]

I do agree with the OP, it is so common for people to just DC from a battle.

 

[Don-Meedo]

i know my friend .. but ppl who disconnect dont care about the rep or 1 disconnect



but other care about winning point



lol i played a complete hard match .. and then the player disconnect and i was going mad from it..

 

[Saric]

that would just make it easier for people to farm wins. All they'd have to do is get a friend and have them relog instead of spending the time to battle.

 

[aezznomore]

I agree with saric.. u can get a whole load of wins just by doing that...

 

[Don-Meedo]

but that will make disconnect like loosing .. it just name different



i agree with you that some ppl will do that .. but i already knoww ppl that battle friends with disadvantage team .. like alakazam lv 40 vs 6 gastly lv 30 .. and battle over and over .. its quicker than disconnect ..



so every thing could be used ..but at least i think we could give the player who play fair his reward 1 win point



dont know maybe something else could be done if we think more about it ..

 

[HeavyPetter]

[quote name='Saric' timestamp='1314650039' post='914']

that would just make it easier for people to farm wins. All they'd have to do is get a friend and have them relog instead of spending the time to battle.

[/quote]



How about putting in a time limit so that you can only battle against the same player once every 5 minutes, that would solve this particular problem. There could also be a limit to how many win points you can get from the same player. That would a least partly solve the problem of "rigged" battles.

 

[mRp.]

[quote name='HeavyPetter' timestamp='1314707667' post='1021']

How about putting in a time limit so that you can only battle against the same player once every 5 minutes, that would solve this particular problem. There could also be a limit to how many win points you can get from the same player. That would a least partly solve the problem of "rigged" battles.

[/quote]



this could be a very good idea , but i dont understand why ppl would want to steal wins.

 

[Dovee]

Well if someone actually disconnects due to faulty internet I dont think its fair to give the other person a win, I know people DC on purpose but because peoples internets actually fail i think it needs to stay the way it is.

 

[Chocobo7]

If your worried about them disconnecting, just use /info playername ingame before a battle, and don't battle anyone who has a high disconnect number.



Also, is there not a message that says when a person has a high d/c rate? <img src="http://www.pokemon-world-online.net/forum/public/style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/MedititeThinking.png" class="bbc_emoticon" alt=":hmm:" />

 

[Don-Meedo]

Chocobo7 yesterday i battled 5 players all d/c was 0 or 1 .. and they all disconnect



some ppl just dont want a lose point in there record so they disconnect





HeavyPetter i think its a great idea <img src="http://www.pokemon-world-online.net/forum/public/style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/ChikoritaSmile.png" class="bbc_emoticon" alt="" />

 

[rbecca]

[quote name='HeavyPetter' timestamp='1314707667' post='1021']

How about putting in a time limit so that you can only battle against the same player once every 5 minutes, that would solve this particular problem. There could also be a limit to how many win points you can get from the same player. That would a least partly solve the problem of "rigged" battles.

[/quote]



Well thought, though, if someone really wants to get those win points, i'm sure they can wait for 5 minutes to battle their friend again to DC again <img src="http://www.pokemon-world-online.net/forum/public/style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/BulbasaurSilly.png" class="bbc_emoticon" alt="" />

I do agree on the limit on how many win points you can get from one player. This could be reset together with the NPC resetting maybe.

People want win points to for example, start a guild, or just brag about it <img src="http://www.pokemon-world-online.net/forum/public/style_emoticons/<#EMO_DIR#>/BulbasaurSilly.png" class="bbc_emoticon" alt="" />

 

[chuck92]

That would be a great idea, every two weeks you could again battle that person and get Wins from them. But does that mean that, lets say after you get 5 wins from them, the next time you battle them you cant get a win, but can you still get a loss against them?

 

[Don-Meedo]

Maybe we could do it the same thing of wining .. like 5 for win and 5 for lose



or like NPC u cant get rep or win untill 1 week or 2



for example : i battle u .. if i win i get 1W and u 1 LP and rep calculated



if i battled u again during 1 week or 2.. both get nothing .. after one week or 2 .. both get point for first battle and etc

 

[Tom210]

idk if this has been said already but it should count as nothing for the person who doesnt disconnect but for the person who does, a disconnect (obviously)

 

[Saric]

[quote name='Tom210' timestamp='1314817586' post='1365']

idk if this has been said already but it should count as nothing for the person who doesnt disconnect but for the person who does, a disconnect (obviously)

[/quote]

That's what it currently is right now. Except for the person who disconnects suffers a loss of rep.

 

[nojo44]

this is a pet peeve but i think them losing rep on it is good enough. but it is annoying so everone, dont do it.

 

[Androziel]

I think the other person should get a win. I know some people accidently DC but i still think its fair to give the other player a win. This coupled with the idea of 5 minute intervals between battles of the same people can make a good combination.

 

[Devious-Honey-C-Sizzle]

I had two people do that to me today, where they battled me and on their last pokemon it said they disconnected.

It confused me. For a while I thought the server was logging people off when they loose.