MrFlare2 said:
Merse said:
God save us from other gen Pokemons. Especially of Gen V "pokes"....
Just gonna point this out, no one really knows how a Pokemon "looks like". You THINK you know but you don't really know. But in short: No one knows how a Pokemon should look like anyways.
(Bonus, if Generation Five and Generation One were swapped, how would you react to Generation Ones Pokemon instead.)
Gen I Pokes were almost all cute or looked cool. They looked similar to animals but meanwhile they were very different from them. You could easily accept that it is another species of "animal" which has special abilities. It was full with fantasy and with original ideas. But look at Gen V! There is no fantasy there. They throw just original animals at you, give them some different color and they say it is Pokemon. It is not, it's a frikkin zoo with a great load of colorful paint!
- Patrat and Watchog: Squirrels with eyes which look like they live on weed. That's all They use the same character design as Chip & Dale 40 years ago.
- Lillipup, Herdier, Stoutland, Purrloin, Liepard: Dogs and cats? Really? Growlithe was a dog but because of its mane it seemed like having fire on his head.
- Pidove, Tranquill, Unfezant: Yeah. Birds whatver. Pidgeotto and Fearow looked much cooler.
- Blitzle, Zebstrika: Electric Zebras???
- Timburr, Gurdurr, Conkeldurr: Even that was strange that Kadabra always has a spoom. But these... Lumber, a steel beam stolen from a construction site, and.... what? Stonehenge?
- Throh and Sawk are one of the worst for me. Really? Human karate masters in blue and red? Hitmontop and Hitmonlee were original, Hitmonchan was OK, but these are just HUMANS dammit! Ok, Mr. Mime was a mistake in this too.
- Sandile, Krokorok, Krookodile: Crocodiles. In the design it has nothing different of a common crocodile except of the colors. Totodile and evos were resembling to crocodiles but at the meantime they were very different.
- Dwebble and Crustle: A hermit-crab and a crab witch takes a boulder on his back?! Why exactly? Again, no idea behind the design.
- Scraggy and Scrafty: A Pokemon which always loses its pants?! Whaaaaaaaaat?! Why a Pokemon wears pants?!
- Sigilyph: A mayan totem.
- Cofagrigus: A Pokemon evolves into a sarcophagus... Yeah, very creative....
- Tirtouga: A turtle. But we already saw this too in better design as Squirtle. Still it is a good design, but there is nothing significantly different from a real life turtle.
- Archen, Archeops: Dafuq?! Archeopteryx and we say it is a Pokemon? Don't even change it ?!?!
- Trubbish and Garbodor: Uhh... A pile of turd.... or waste... or garbage.... Yeeeeeshhh. Disgusting. And Grimer/Muk was way more creative.
- Gothorita, Gothitelle: Goth girls who look like Betty Boop? Seriously?
- Ducklett, Swanna: The ducks from Tom & Jerry. About 60 years old design with almost no change at all. Very creative again.
- Vanillish and Vanilluxe: Errr.... Ice cream. As Pokemons. What?
- Deerling and Sawsbuck: Look Mom, it's Bambi! At least Stantler had a bulldog face and antler looking like big eyes. But these lack any creativity.
- Emolga: A flying Pikachu.... Well kinda creative. Kinda.
- Escavalier: The lowest of the low, the worst of the bad. a cavalier? A middle-age human riding warrior sold to us as a Pokemon. This was the point where I knew that Gen V is hopeless.
- Foongus and Amoonguss: Mushrooms with Pokeball-signs on their hat. I mean... seriously? A Pokemon evolved to have exactly the same pattern on its head as a Pokéball? ANYTHING would have been better than that.
- Ferroseed and Ferrothorn: Foretress on steroids. Too bad we already saw this in Gen II
- Klink, Klang and Klinklang: Gears?!?!?!?!?!?!
- Lampent and Chandelure: CHANDELIERS?!?!?!
- Cubchoo and Beartic: An icebear who has cold and another which has too much fur on its lower body........
- Cryogonal: Snow flake. I can't even be outraged any more. This is pathetic.
- Rufflet and Braviary: Eagles. Yeah, tease the Big American Ego a bit. Otherwise it is an acceptable design.
- Mandibuzz: A perfect copy of the vultures from the Book of the Jungle. With the exception that this one is female.
- Durant: An ant. A frikkin ant! As a Pokémon?
- Landorus: You get this if Entei meets Raikou and then a big bole is stuck in the offspring's head.
- Genesect: I can't rmemeber its name but there was a Transformer drawn in the 80s which looked just like this.
I rechecked all the 649 Pokemons, to be sure, but I have no doubt, Gen V has the stupidest the most minimalistic and most uninspired Pokémon designs of all. Gen IV was very weak, Gen V is just unacceptable.
The only thing that can repair a bit on Gen V's reputation are the new ideas and the nice gameplay.