matileo19 said:
Contagion said:
Dovee said:
There was times before when a slaking could kill a meta if it got lucky and FP hit every time. Now there is no way you can kill one. Slaking is stronger against what because of hammer arm? It takes a bit less damage from snorlax and tauros now okay it still beats them but it loses speed in the process. Also HA doesnt make a difference of when its facing the pokemon that can already kill it like charizard jolteon and starmie.
Correct me if I'm wrong Dovee, you're a much more knowledgeable player than I am... and truth be told I haven't done *much* testing with Slaking since the updates... but as I go over scenarios and numbers in my head I agree with Petter, it seems Slaking was made more powerful with this update.
The slowing down helps and I see the logic behind it. I think what it's done is make Slaking less able to plow through 3 pokes... but let's be honest, at high levels we aren't seeing that kind of dominance from Slaking anymore because top battlers are bringing some of the counters you mentioned.
It has however minimized the damage other normal type regular battlers can do before exiting. If my Snorlax ran into a Slaking, I could do enough damage for my Kazam, Gengar, Tauros, Starmie, Char, Sala etc to one hit Slaking next turn. Threat neutralized.
Furthermore, counters like Rhydon and Steelix now get worked by Slak.
Anyway, I'll keep testing, but I think reducing HA power by another 10 bp would help...
The main problem are the stats on slaking... Dunno who said it, but Slak should atk 1 time for each 2 turns. If you don't have an Slak in your team your opponent will get an incredible advantage on you. Im not using slak in my team and Is still very hard for me (considering that I own over 25 pokemons, all with good / uber stats) What about those who don't have pokemons with good/uber stats and/or over 25 battlers?
Hammer arm is less powerfull than FP, okey... But the spd doesn't matters at all, Rock/Steel types don't have good spd to face it anyway lol... I'll give you my analisys, using my experience (Old and new experience, using and not using Slak)
Pokemons that were able to kill Slak before the update:
If an Slak has less Spd:
Chari
Shiny Primeape
Raichu
Electabuzz
Manectric
If the move dont miss:
Jolteon
Starmie
If FP miss:
Metagross
Shiny Rhydon
Shiny Steelix
Snorlax (
Probably)
Tyranitar (
Probably)
Aerodactyl
Others:
Shiny Exeggutor
A total of 14 pokes (Short list)
With the update:
If an Slak has less Spd ( The update will not affect this list ):
Chari (
You will not use Hammer arm agains Chari)
Shiny Primeape (
You will not use Hammer arm against S prime)
Raichu (
You will not use Hammer arm agains Raichu)
Electabuzz (
You will not use Hammer arm agains Electa)
Manectric (
You will not use Hammer arm agains Manec)
If the move dont miss (What I said before):
Jolteon
Starmie
If FP miss:
Metagross (
Can kill Slak, unless Meta has bad stats, I may be wrong )
Shiny Rhydon (
cant kill Slak)
Shiny Steelix (
cant kill Slak)
Snorlax (
cant kill Slak)
Tyranitar (
cant kill Slak)
Aerodactyl (
cant kill Slak)
Others:
Shiny Exeggutor
A total of 9... lol
Im saying what I saw and I am constantly doing battles.
I think this is LARGELY miss-informed and mistaken. At least in general, most of this information is relatively wrong or lacks further analysis and information.
Reasons :
If an Slak has less Spd:
Chari (Doesn't kill an Uber HP/SP Def slaking 100% of the time. If one minimum Flare Blitz hit occurs, Slaking Survives)
Shiny Primeape (Actually has a 20% chance to miss. Same as Starmie)
Raichu (If charizard with 109 base spatk and flare blitz having 100% Accuracy struggles, I have no clue how Raichu would kill one. Unless Thunderwave)
Electabuzz (Look @ Raichu)
Manectric (Same poke as Jolteon, so I have no clue why he's here)
If the move dont miss:
Jolteon (Refer to Charizard)
Starmie (Refer to Charizard)
If FP miss:
Metagross (One thing thats true)
Shiny Rhydon (Rhydon would need to land 4 Earthquakes to kill a Slaking. Slaking has a 50% Chance to land One FP. So you have a 12.5% chance of not hitting Rhydon, meaning odds are in your favor. 50% Chance to beat Rhydon if you insist on using FP all the way)
Shiny Steelix (Even worst odds than Rhydon, considering it'll take about 5-6 DE's to kill Slaking)
Snorlax (
Probably) (Only poke harshly influenced by the update to Hammer Arm)
Tyranitar (
Probably) (Tyranitar would take about 4-5 Crunch's to kill Slaking. Saying Probably is a BIG mistake. Considering you only have a 12.5% or less to lose this fight)
Aerodactyl (lol? You can slash 90% of aeros to death)
Others:
Shiny Exeggutor (If slaking has uber Attack, Exegg will never beat Slaking unless he chooses to go with sleep powder.)
Seeing as people think this is a GREAT analysis I had to intervene. There are way too many mistakes and missing information.
Technically, there is only 1 poke that was able to take out Slaking before Update 99% of the time and that was Metagross. With update, this hasn't changed.
I do agree that the introduction of Hammer Arm to Slaking is an improvement to him since his Expected Damage is greater than the one he did with Focus Punch.
Personally, I don't think the issue lies in the fact that Slaking's stats are really high. The issue lies in the fact that the wrong pokes are being updated. Introduction of Hammer Arm to Rhydon, Metagross, Swampert would introduce new effective counters to Slaking. Introduction of Close Combat to all the fighting pokes would lessen his influence in the battle scene.
I personally think simply removing Hammer arm AND Focus Punch from slaking would be enough in the meantime. Though I'm insistent on disagreeing with any analysis Mati has done due to lack of information or misguiding information.
Also, those who think reducing the Attack stat of slaking would rebalance it are largely misguided. Slaking is a speedy tank. That's where he excels. He is able to take enough hits AND hit first. The damage outlay is relatively irrelevant to him compared to other stats. Consider the fact that a max hp, max defense and max spd slaking would never die to anypoke other than Metagross, unless Charizard moves first AND gets TWO max % flare blitz. If you were to modify any Stats, it would end up being HP, since a decrease from 450 to 350, would make him largely more vulnerable to all attacks that he incurs.
ALSO : Why are people upset about chip away? It's completely irrelevant. It does same damage as Slash. I don't understand why people think it's better at all.